Brazil's Senator Suplicy in Video Appeal: We Must Close Loopholes in Brazil’s Bill to Ban Cosmetics Animal Testing or Animals Remain Unprotected

#BeCrueltyFree Brazil calls for a FULL ban, not a FALSE ban

SAO PAULO (19 Aug 2014)—Senator Eduardo Suplicy has launched a video appeal to his fellow senators, alerting them to serious loopholes in Bill PLC 70/2014 intended to ban animal testing of cosmetics. The video also features Anna Andrade from cruelty-free retailer LUSH Cosmetics, Dr. Vania Nunes, technical director of the National Forum for the Protection and Defence of Animals (FNPDA), European Union policy expert, Emily McIvor, from animal protection group Humane Society International and Helder Constantino from the Be Cruelty-Free Brazil campaign.

The Chamber of Deputies passed the bill (formerly PL 6602/13) in June, but negotiations with the government severely compromised it by proposing only a ban on finished cosmetic product testing on animals without including a ban on ingredients testing. The majority of animals are used for testing ingredients. The bill is due to be discussed by the Commission of Science and Technology and the Environment Commission, but Sen. Suplicy and Be Cruelty-Free Brazil warn that unless it is amended, potentially thousands of rabbits and other animals will remain at risk from painful testing for cosmetic ingredients.

Sen. Suplicy says: “Animal testing for finished products almost never happens in Brazil. So this part of the ban has virtually no purpose. Most of the animal tests are for cosmetic ingredients and in this regard the bill does not attack the focal point of the problem, leaving the door open for companies to continue animal testing.”

Be Cruelty-Free campaigners believe that the Senate must allocate sufficient time for PLC 70/2014 to be debated in depth and amended so that it can effectively save animals from cosmetic tests.

Helder Constantino for Be Cruelty-Free Brazil, said: “Be Cruelty-Free has campaigned tremendously hard for the past two years to achieve a ban on cosmetics animal testing here in Brazil, so we understand only too well the desire to see a ban in place. But if that ban is so fundamentally flawed that in practice it stops virtually no animal suffering at all, what is the point of that? This is a well-intentioned bill whose aims we support, but it is badly written. We are urging senators to accept our proposals to deliver the full ban on cosmetics cruelty that Brazilians want to see, or Brazil will be left with a toothless piece of legislation that fails to save the animals it aims to protect.”

Cosmetics animal testing is already banned across the European Union, Norway, Israel and India. Emily McIvor, policy director for HSI’s Research & Toxicology Department, played a central role in achieving the EU ban, receiving the prestigious Henry Spira award in 2011 in recognition of her outstanding contribution to animal welfare policy. McIvor echoes Sen. Suplicy’s concerns that Brazil’s animal test ban bill must be watertight:

“For any test ban to be considered complete, it must ban all animal testing for ingredients. It’s crucial that Brazil bans both tests on products and ingredients, and that it does so with watertight language just as the EU, India and others have done. If the language isn’t right, the test ban can be abused.”

Be Cruelty-Free Brazil is part of the largest campaign in the world to end cosmetics animal testing. The Be Cruelty-Free Brazil campaign, led by Humane Society International and supported by ProAnima, ARCA Brasil and the Forum Nacional de Proteção e Defesa Animal, is leading the nationwide effort for a ban on cosmetics animal testing. Be Cruelty-Free campaigns also run in Australia, Canada, China, India, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, Russia, Taiwan and the United States, where the campaign is led by The Humane Society of the United States. 

Watch the #BeCrueltyFree Brazil video here.


Media contact: 

Wendy Higgins, Communications Director: 44 (0)7989 972 423, 

A Humane Society International (HSI) e suas organizações parceiras constituem juntas uma das maiores e mais importantes organizações de proteção animal do mundo. Por mais de 20 anos, a HSI vem lutando para a proteção de todos os animais por meio de trabalhos de conscientização, educação e programas práticos. HSI: Celebrando todos os animais e confrontando a crueldade em todo o mundo:


About Us

Humane Society International and its partner organisations together constitute one of the world’s largest animal protection organisations. For more than 20 years, HSI has been working for the protection of all animals through the use of science, advocacy, education and hands on programs. Our key campaigns include Kill the Cull opposing England's badger cull; Be Cruelty-Free to end animal testing of cosmetics; CITES and wildlife protection; Love Spain Hate Bullfighting. Celebrating animals and confronting cruelty worldwide – on the Web at Be Cruelty-Free is the largest campaign in the world to end cosmetics animal testing. Globally HSI is leading the charge to end cosmetics cruelty in Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, Russia, Taiwan and Be Cruelty-Free USA is spearheaded by The Humane Society of the United States. On the web at