Top 4 Best Sportsbooks in Indiana — IN Sports Betting Apps Ranked by User Experience, Withdrawal Speed, and More

Report this content

When the US Supreme Court overturned PASPA (Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act) in 2018, many states rushed to introduce sports betting to their residents. While some states still have a hostile stance towards any gambling form, others have welcomed these changes with open arms. 

Indiana legalized sports betting in May 2019, when Gov. Eric Holcomb signed and passed HB 1015 into law. The first retail sportsbooks went live in September 2019, just in time for the football season, while online websites and apps entered the scene a month later. At the moment, Indiana residents have access to 12 top-of-the-line sportsbooks, with more to come in the future.

However, since not all of them operate on the same level, we decided to take a closer look, review them, and present you with the four best betting sites currently available in the Hoosier State. 

Why should you trust us? Well, after years of experience in betting on international sportsbooks, we finally got the chance to try US-based sites and see what they had to offer. We followed the entire procedure down to a T — we registered accounts, funded them, explored the platforms, and tested some of their betting options and features. 

After looking under every rock and thoroughly inspecting the offers, we were finally able to name our top four sportsbooks operating in Indiana. Ultimately, DraftKings prevailed and was crowned the best sportsbook in the Hoosier State. Of course, that’s not to say other betting platforms are bad. On the contrary, each one has its own strengths, as you will be able to see in the review below. 

If you’re ready to learn more about the top online sportsbooks in Indiana, scroll down and keep reading.

Top 3 Most Visited Online Sportsbooks in Indiana

  1. DraftKings

  2. BetMGM

  3. Unibet

After long hours of reviewing and testing sportsbooks, we finally ended up with a list of the four most popular sports betting sites frequented by Indiana bettors. Once we had the names, we decided to examine them further and give you an unbiased assessment for each one. To do that, we had to look into the most important sections — licensing and security information, bonuses and promotions, betting markets and odds, payment options, device compatibility, customer support, and ranking.

Once we scoured each site, we could finally put together a list and rank them based on their overall performance. 

First Look at the 4 Best Online Sportsbooks in Indiana

Before we get into further details of each sportsbook, we’d like to briefly introduce you to our top four and explain the lineup. Choosing the winner wasn’t easy — all sportsbooks offered fantastic betting options, so we had to take our search to the next level and focus on particular elements that would separate platforms from one another. 

By doing so, we came to the conclusion that DraftKings is the perfect example of what a renowned sportsbook should look like. Some of the aspects that led us to our decision include the hefty welcome bonus of up to $200, a wide range of pre-match and in-play betting options, fast payouts, Flash Bets feature, and so much more. 

Here’s what our final list of the top four sportsbooks in Indiana looks like:

  1. DraftKings

  2. BetMGM

  3. Unibet

  4. BetRivers

Detailed Reviews of the 4 Top-Rated Indiana Sportsbooks

The following paragraphs contain reviews of each sportsbook’s most important aspects. These will help you understand our ranking decision and give you a clear idea of what to expect from every operator. Once you’re done reading, you’ll be able to decide which platform meets your needs and expectations. 

DraftKings — Best Overall Betting Experience

DraftKings has been with Indiana sports betting enthusiasts from the very beginning. It was the first bookie to open its virtual doors and welcome all interested players in the Hoosier State. Despite being primarily known as a daily fantasy sports platform, DraftKings also offers state-of-the-art sportsbook products and a betting app. 

Through its partnership with Penn National Gaming, DraftKings brings fantastic odds and a wide range of pre-match and live betting options. With its Flash Bets feature, the bookie offers unparalleled betting speed and effectiveness. New players are entitled to a hefty welcome bonus, while the existing ones have access to rewarding ongoing promotions. 


  • Wide range of lucrative promotions

  • Huge selection of sports betting opportunities

  • Flash Bets feature

  • In-play betting

  • Reliable sportsbook app


  • Improvements necessary in the Customer Support department

BetMGM — Fastest Payouts

MGM partnered with Boyd Gaming, which operates Belterra Casino in Florence, Indiana, and launched the renowned BetMGM sportsbook. It was the fourth betting platform to go live in the Hoosier State. 

The bookie offers a variety of options — from major leagues to niche sports and events. iOS and Android users can easily download apps and use them to place bets on the go. With a slew of secure payment methods, responsive customer support, and a user-friendly interface, BetMGM is an excellent choice for Indiana bettors. Thanks to reputable payment systems, like PayPal, credit and debit cards, or Play+, BetMGM provides fast payouts to its members.


  • Free game live-streaming

  • Polished mobile and desktop interface

  • Variety of sports and betting options

  • Generous welcome bonus 


  • M Life Rewards unattainable by casual bettors

Unibet — Best Welcome Bonus

An agreement between Unibet and Horseshoe Casino Hammond allowed the European heavyweight to enter the Indiana market and launch its product. Despite the fact that it isn’t widely known in the U.S., you shouldn’t dismiss Unibet without giving it a shot.

After years of hands-on experience, this bookie has become the leader in the sector. New players can kickstart their adventure with a risk-free bets bonus up to $600 and use it to test the product. Although the operator has yet to introduce an iOS mobile app, players can still access the mobile version of the website and enjoy an all-encompassing betting experience


  • Well-established name in the industry

  • Platform and app easy to use

  • Fast and reliable payouts

  • Impressive bonuses and promotions


  • Customer support not available 24/7

  • No iOS mobile app


BetRivers — Most Advanced Loyalty Program

Launched on the same day as DraftKings, BetRivers brings a first-class sports wagering experience to Indiana residents. Along with Rush Street Interactive and Kambi, BetRivers partnered with French Lick Resort and launched the top-of-the-line online sportsbook.

Besides the easy-to-navigate platform and dedicated apps, BetRives also stands out from the crowd thanks to its well-executed iRewards loyalty program created specifically for online users. 

Despite sporting the old-fashioned look, BetRivers carries fantastic wagering options. Here, you will get to bet on major leagues, TV shows, and other unique events like the Academy Awards. It also hosts superb odds and reliable customer support. Thanks to its long-standing experience, BetRivers managed to meet our high expectations and make the final cut.


  • Excellent promotions

  • Detailed iRewards loyalty program

  • Superb customer support

  • Extensive range of betting opportunities

  • First-rate odds


  • Slightly outdated design

  • No DFS betting options

Online Sportsbooks in Indiana FAQ

What is the best online sportsbook in Indiana?

Essentially, this answer is a matter of personal preference. You know best which sports you like to follow and what you want to gain from a betting experience. Our job was to give an honest and objective opinion and help you understand what to expect from each platform. 

However, based on every aspect we reviewed, DraftKings came out on top, as it excelled in all categories. Members of this sportsbook have access to superb odds, fantastic betting options, and special features that help it stand out from the rest — not to mention that the site is fully licensed and welcomes its players with a hefty welcome bonus.   

Is online sports betting legal in Indiana?

Simply put — yes, online sports betting is legal in the Hoosier State. On May 8, 2019, Gov. Eric Holcomb signed the historical HB 1015 into the law, making both retail and online sports betting legal. The entire online and retail gambling industry, including sportsbooks, is regulated by the Indiana Gaming Commission (IGC). 

The first brick-and-mortar sportsbooks opened their doors in September 2019, and their online counterparts soon followed. BetRivers and DraftKings were the first two betting platforms to launch in the Hoosier State on October 3, 2019. Currently, Indiana betting enthusiasts have access to 12 renowned sportsbooks.  

What sports can I bet on in Indiana?

Unlike other states, Indiana doesn’t allow betting on esports. Nevertheless, the range of available betting options is comprehensive. Major leagues, such as the NBA, NFL, NHL, and MLB, dominate the market, while college leagues and tournaments, like March Madness, are a close second. Other popular betting options include tennis, golf, MMA, boxing, motorsports, rugby, cycling, cricket, etc.

However, the state of Indiana handles horse racing differently. This sports betting category is already available via apps like TVG and BetAmerica, but it isn’t included in the new wave of IN sportsbooks. 

What type of bets can I place in Indiana sportsbooks?

Indiana sportsbooks offer an all-encompassing betting experience. The platforms have full functionality, allowing you to choose among a wide range of bets — singles, parlays, futures, and a couple of exotic proposition bets. 

More experienced bettors have a chance to test their prediction skills in live betting, which is something many sports enthusiasts wish to master. You’ll also have access to the classic bets like totals, moneyline, and spreads, while robin rounds and teasers are also an option.


We finally reached the end of our guide to the best Indiana sportsbooks. While creating the list hasn’t been easy, we believe that our final lineup consists of reputable and secure bookies offering a superb betting experience, each in their own special way. 

As we’ve said, DraftKings came out on top as the top-performing sportsbook, but others were not too far behind. Still, it ultimately comes down to your preferences and expectations. By reading reviews about each Indiana sportsbook, you’ve probably got the idea of what they have in store for their members. Now, all that’s left is for you to do is choose one and start betting on your favorite sports.

We review online casinos to give our users the perfect experience online. All recommendations are absolutely 100% independent, driven by the research that we drive.

Thanks to our website, huge numbers of gamers have found the casino that they mainly use to play online. This has led to a large base of happy users regularly using some of the worlds best casino options.